How We Actually Use AI in Small Business Marketing (And What It’s Not For)
James Lajoie • December 30, 2025

There’s a lot of noise right now about AI in marketing. Some people are acting like it’s going to replace teams. Others think it’s a magic button that runs their business for them.

Graphic showing the logos of ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, and Perplexity as popular AI tools for small business marketing.

Neither is true.

AI isn’t here to replace thinking, strategy, or people. It’s here to remove friction — especially in marketing, where a lot of time is spent on drafting, organizing, researching, and iterating before anything ever gets in front of a customer.

Used correctly, AI helps us move faster and smarter for our clients. Used poorly, it just creates more noise.

Here’s how we think about it and how we actually use it.


What AI Is Good At in Marketing

AI is good at:

  • Drafting first versions of content, ads, and emails
  • Turning rough ideas into structured plans
  • Summarizing research and performance data
  • Generating variations so we can test faster
  • Speeding up execution so strategy can stay human-led

That’s the value.

AI doesn’t know your customers. It doesn’t understand your market. It doesn’t know what makes your business different or what your brand should sound like.

That part is still human.

We use AI as a tool inside the process — not as the process.


How We Use AI for Clients

Here are a few real examples of where it helps:


Strategy & Planning

We use AI to:

  • Combine different data points into structured summaries
  • Pressure-test ideas (“what if we focus on X instead of Y?”)
  • Create initial outlines for campaigns and funnels

It helps us think faster, not think for us.


Content & Creative

We use AI to:

  • Draft blog outlines
  • Generate headline and ad copy variations
  • Write first-pass emails and landing page content

Then we refine everything based on brand voice, customer psychology, and what we know actually works.


Research & Optimization

We use AI to:

  • Summarize competitive landscapes
  • Review trends and audience behavior
  • Analyze performance data and extract insights

Again, speed — not replacement.


The Tools We Use (and Why)

We primarily use a few tools depending on the job:

  • ChatGPT for drafting, structuring ideas, and marketing workflows
  • Claude for longer writing and internal documentation
  • Gemini for data-heavy research and analysis
  • Perplexity for fast research with sources

Each tool has strengths. None of them “think.”

They respond to how they’re guided.


Why Prompting Matters

AI output is only as good as the input.

If you ask it vague questions, you get vague answers. If you give it context — your industry, your goals, your audience, your constraints — it becomes useful.

That’s why we don’t just “ask AI.” We frame it properly based on real business context.

That’s the difference between AI being noise and AI being leverage.


Where Businesses Go Wrong With AI

We see a few common mistakes:

  • Using AI to replace thinking instead of support it
  • Publishing unedited AI content that sounds generic and untrustworthy
  • Treating AI like a shortcut instead of a tool
  • Ignoring brand voice, customer psychology, and positioning

AI can make bad marketing faster just as easily as it can make good marketing faster.

The difference is judgment.



The Bottom Line

AI is not a marketing strategy.

It’s a tool inside a strategy.

It won’t replace experience, creativity, or understanding your customer — but it does remove friction so more energy can go into those things.

That’s how we use it, and that’s why it’s useful.

If you’re a small business owner wondering whether AI matters for you — the answer isn’t “yes” or “no.” It’s “how.”

Used thoughtfully, it’s a real advantage. Used blindly, it’s just another thing to manage.

Share this Blog Post on Social Media

A glossy 3D Threads logo featuring a raised white “@” symbol centered over bold, multicolored radial
By James Lajoie October 30, 2025
Discover how small and medium-sized businesses can use Threads in 2025 to build brand awareness, connect with audiences, and drive engagement—without paid ads. Learn who’s on Threads, when to post, and how to craft content that converts conversations into community.
Graphic: AI, SEO, and GEO icons represent the new marketing trio.
By James Lajoie October 9, 2025
Discover how AIO (Artificial Intelligence Optimization), SEO, and GEO are reshaping organic marketing. Learn how businesses can show up in AI results, boost visibility, and dominate local and global search using AI SEO services, digital marketing with AI, and automation.
By Axel Martinez September 18, 2025
At PSP Compass Solutions, we believe business owners should be empowered to grow. One way to do that is by shaping how customers remember your brand — because if you don’t, they’ll fill in the blanks themselves.
A row of colorful cans of soda with fruit on them.
By Aldona Ciszek July 3, 2025
Discover how Poppi scaled to $500M using a marketing-led strategy — and what business owners can learn to grow faster, smarter, and more authentically.
A diagram of the 7ps marketing mix to drive business success
By James Lajoie June 29, 2025
Marketing in today’s competitive landscape requires a well-rounded approach that addresses every aspect of the customer experience. The 7Ps marketing mix is a proven framework that helps businesses create strategies tailored to their market and customer needs. This guide breaks down each of the 7Ps and offers clear exa
Illustration of a local business listing concept with a desktop screen displaying a map, surrounded
By James Lajoie February 15, 2025
Ensure your business stands out online by listing it on high-authority directories like Google, Bing, Facebook, and Instagram. Learn why NAP consistency (Name, Address, Phone Number) is crucial for SEO and customer trust. Get a free listing report today!
A realistic scene of a smartphone displaying a Google search for 'nail salons near me,' with an 'Ask
By James Lajoie February 11, 2025
Google has introduced "Ask for Me," an experimental AI feature designed to handle phone inquiries on your behalf. Whether you're looking for service pricing, appointment availability, or business details, this tool aims to streamline the process—saving users time while leveraging Google's Duplex technology. But how will businesses respond to AI-driven calls? While some may welcome the automation, others might struggle with the shift. With opt-out options and call quotas in place, Google is balancing efficiency with business preferences.
Illustration depicting Google's algorithm updates in December 2024 and January
By James Lajoie February 2, 2025
In this blog post, we explore Google's recent algorithm updates and their implications for your business. We'll provide practical advice on how to adjust your SEO strategies in response to the December 2024 Core and Spam Updates, as well as the January 2025 Local Ranking changes. Stay informed and keep your website performing at its best.
A close up of the google app on a phone
By James Lajoie December 16, 2024
Google’s November 2024 Core Update is complete, and it brings changes that small to medium businesses need to know. From prioritizing high-quality content to emphasizing user experience and trustworthiness, this update could impact your website's rankings. Learn how these changes might affect your business and get actionable tips to adapt and stay competitive. Read more on PSPCompass.com.
A sales funnel with awareness , consideration , and decision.
By James Lajoie November 17, 2024
The Ultimate Guide to Aligning Your Content Strategy with Sales Goals